Josef Höving
Josef Höving
Manufacturing Automation · · 7 min read

Compact or Central Storage System? Which Solution Fits Your Carrier Mix

The wrong question is: "How much storage do I need?" The right one is: "What role should the storage system play in the material flow?" Once that is answered, the system decision almost makes itself.

Which automated storage system fits an SMT operation depends less on the available technology than on the role the storage system should play in the material flow: a line-side buffer for a manageable range of material, or a central supply and circulation hub for several lines with a highly dynamic mix. That role sets the requirements for throughput, product mix, returns, and IT integration, and only then does the system choice follow.

In our consulting work, we often meet the same starting point: an operation is growing, the carrier mix is getting more complex, and at some point the status quo is no longer enough. The question then is whether a compact, line-side system will do or whether a central storage system with more capacity and process structure is needed.

That is why we do not evaluate this decision on capacity figures alone. What matters is which task the storage system should take on in the overall material flow and which requirements follow from that for the operation.


Compact and central storage system compared

A compact storage system such as cts OCTA Storage works as a line-side buffer with storage logic, while a central one such as cts CUBE Storage serves as a supply and circulation hub for several lines. The differences show up across seven criteria:

Criterion cts OCTA Storage cts CUBE Storage
Primary role Line-side buffer with storage logic Central supply and circulation hub
Suited for Few lines, manageable material mix, clear supply routines Several lines, highly dynamic mix, many returns and carrier types
Access times Very short thanks to proximity to the line Longer internal paths, offset by a better zone structure
Zoning Limited, works well with a homogeneous mix Extensive, clean separation of carrier types, returns, and exceptions
Scalability Modular expansion as an OCTA cluster Designed for growth from the outset
Changeover peaks Buffers manageable peaks More robust with highly dynamic returns
Footprint Compact, can sit close to the line More floor space, central placement makes sense

The questions that lead to the storage system choice

We do not rely on gut feeling here but on a brief look at processes and volumes. Four questions structure the decision in practice, and each one shifts the tendency in one direction:

1
How many lines need to be supplied, and how often is material accessed? A few lines with high replenishment frequency point to OCTA, because short paths and fast access are the main benefit there. Several lines with parallel demand point to CUBE as central supply with process decoupling.
2
How high is the share of returns, and how complex are returns and exceptions? With manageable returns and little exception handling, the standard paths of an OCTA are sufficient. With a high share of returns and many exceptions, the clean zone separation of a CUBE is needed.
3
Do reels dominate the carrier mix? Then it is worth considering a specialized reel storage system and using OCTA or CUBE only for the remaining carrier mix.
4
How much will the mix grow over the next few years? A stable mix with predictable growth points to OCTA, which can be expanded as a cluster. A fast-growing mix with new carrier types points to CUBE, which stays manageable where an OCTA would become hard to follow because of added special rules.

In practice, the four answers rarely all point in the same direction. A few lines combined with a fast-growing mix, or a small area with a high share of returns, are typical mixed cases. What decides then is which question describes the biggest bottleneck, while the other answers determine how much reserve or which combination makes sense. This is where looking at real volumes instead of assumptions pays off, because peaks and returns in daily operations often look different than in the plan.


Where a compact storage system works and where it reaches its limits

cts OCTA Storage works very well when a clearly defined supply area needs to be organized efficiently and formats and processes do not diverge too much. A typical case is one or two lines with clear supply routines, where fast handovers and orderly returns bring the greatest benefit. Limitations arise when many carrier types with very different return and handling logic have to be separated cleanly at the same time, or when returns and exceptions take up too much floor space and operator time.

Typical growth problem

The difference between OCTA and CUBE usually does not show at the first expansion but at the second or third. When new carrier types are added or the mix grows significantly, an OCTA risks becoming hard to follow because of added special rules.

For context: A physical expansion of the CUBE involves downtime for reconfiguration and recommissioning. In practice, future-proof initial sizing with enough reserve is therefore preferred. Expansion with an additional storage system is possible, integrated into the existing system landscape rather than as a parallel world next to MES and ERP.

Reels in the carrier mix: a specialized storage system as a building block

When component reels are the dominant bottleneck, a universal storage system is often not the best answer. cts REEL Storage is specialized for reels: vertical storage, flexible slot management without rigid size constraints, and an optional climate zone for moisture sensitive devices (MSD). For very limited floor space, cts REEL Tower offers a tower configuration.

In reel-heavy SMT manufacturing, this often leads to a hybrid approach: a reel storage system as a specialized building block plus OCTA or CUBE for the remaining carrier mix of small load carriers (KLTs), trays, and magazines. Each building block handles the task it was designed for.


Which scenarios point to which storage system

The four questions lead to recurring scenarios in practice that allow a first assessment:

Compact

cts OCTA Storage

Few lines, manageable material mix, main benefit in fast handovers and orderly returns. High-runner areas or clear supply routines without strong changeover dynamics.

Central

cts CUBE Storage

Several lines with a highly dynamic mix, many returns, and different carrier types, or the deliberate setup of a central hub for storage, buffering, and returns.

Reels

cts REEL Storage

A focused solution, useful when component reels are the dominant bottleneck and no universal storage system is needed.

Combination

Hybrid approach

Reel storage for reels plus OCTA or CUBE for the remaining carrier mix. The storage logic is integrated so that later expansion does not cause a system break.

IT integration in every variant: MES and ERP remain the higher-level systems, and the line software handles identification and consumption. The storage system reports states and movements through open interfaces, regardless of whether OCTA, CUBE, or a reel storage system is in use.

What the choice of storage system does not solve

The right storage system organizes line supply, but it does not fix problems that arise before or after storage. Three limits should be clear before the decision:

Missing zone roles

If it is not defined which zone handles replenishment, returns, and exceptions, disorder builds up in any system; in a large one, it simply covers more floor space.

Wrong placement

Material needed within the running cycle belongs at the line, not in storage. The storage system does not make that decision for you.

Unclear volume data

Without figures on peaks, access, and returns, every system choice remains an estimate. That is why the process and volume view comes before the quote.

This calls for a self-critical look: as a supplier of both systems, we have an interest in the larger solution, and a central storage system is the safer recommendation on paper. For an operation with few lines and a stable mix, however, it would be oversized and would cost floor space and travel paths that a compact system saves.

Conclusion: the storage system choice follows the process

Neither OCTA nor CUBE is the better storage system across the board. The decision follows from the process: which peaks occur, how often material is accessed, how many returns arise, where search times and stoppages happen, and which protection requirements apply? Answering these questions soberly shows whether a compact line-side system is enough, whether a central hub is needed, or whether a combination offers the best balance of benefit, effort, and scalability.


Which storage system fits your operation?

Together with you, we look at peaks, carrier mix, share of returns, and protection requirements and show which solution offers the greatest leverage.

Talk to our specialists